Super Comboman is the latest indie title to be picked up by Adult Swim Games. The cable network-turned-game publisher has become relatively well-known on the PC for helping out indie games that are not unlike their own TV shows: Quirky, surreal, and lighthearted in nature. Bonus points if the games are really difficult and/or have a retro-inspired aesthetic with old school mechanics. Volgarr the Viking and Super House of Dead Ninjas are two of their more well-known publishing efforts, but whereas those games are extremely challenging for being well-designed throwbacks to classic arcade and NES/SNES titles, Super Comboman is frustratingly difficult because of sloppy mechanics and poor design decisions.

Super Comboman is a 2D brawler with some platforming and puzzle elements that has you take on the role of Struggles, a comic nerd that is obsessed about a superhero named Super Comboman. Using a repertoire of fancy moves inspired by his favorite hero, Struggles takes up a job spanning some 16 levels. Progression resembles a traditional brawler, where you start out with a small set of moves and buy more over the course of the game. However, the combat plays a bit more like a fighting game, with an emphasis on building up huge combos and special moves that require a combination of directional inputs combined with one of several attack buttons.

Super Comboman game still 3The problem that becomes immediately obvious is that this game has some cripplingly bad input lag. While your death can be blamed on your own ineptitude in other, more polished brawlers, here you’ll often feel like your failures are directly due to the unresponsive controls. Many, many times I’ve hit the block or parry buttons only to have nothing happen. The input lag makes some of the more complicated moves harder to pull off than they really should be as well. Your character also has a bad tendency to “stick” to things, making it hard to disengage from enemies. This, combined with the input lag and tendency of enemies to stun lock you, means that getting stuck between two enemies is usually a death sentence. While the AI is pretty good at stun locking you to death, they are really bad at basic level navigation. They will rarely chase after you if you leave them behind, and they can’t do any sort of platforming, often leaving them stuck behind barrels and other objects.

Besides buying new moves, you can also buy and equip perks. You can have two of these passives equipped at a time, and they only activate once you get to a certain combo number and stay active as long as you maintain your combo. There is nothing wrong with this idea in itself, but the perk system falls apart when you take the game’s level design into account. By the time you build up a big enough combo to have both perks active, you are usually out of enemies or objects to punch to keep your combo going. Since the levels also tend to have stretches of platforming or puzzles with no enemies, this creates a situation where you will rarely have your perks active for more than a second or two, making the whole system a waste of your time and money.

In addition to your standard attacks and special moves, there is a smash attack that can be performed when the Smash meter in the bottom left corner of the screen recharges. The smash is a powerful attack that usually sends enemies or objects flying across the screen, and many of the game’s physics and environmental puzzles are based around this attack. The problem here is that there isn’t much consistency when it comes to how your smash attack interacts with the environment and enemies. Sometimes you’ll send an enemy flying across the screen, slamming him into other enemies and knocking them all down like bowling pins. Other times the enemy won’t move at all after being smashed, or they’ll only fly a few feet and do nothing to the enemies they came into contact with.

Super Comboman game still 2

This lack of consistency gets especially frustrating when you must smash enemies into buttons or other objects in the environment to continue. There are several puzzles where you must smash an enemy into a strategically-placed mattress, which in theory will send them bouncing upward into a button you can’t reach. In practice, you’ll often need to retry these puzzles multiple times because the enemy didn’t react correctly to being smashed into the mattress.

Joining in on the lack of consistency is the game’s approach to checkpoints. The game uses a three lives system, and you’ll occasionally gain new lives during a level. As long as you have lives left, you’ll respawn at the last checkpoint. Once you run out, you’ll need to start the level over again. Fair enough, many games in this genre take such an approach to lives and checkpoints. In Super Comboman though, checkpoints are either too close together or way too far apart. Some levels give you so many checkpoints that there isn’t much consequence to dying once or twice, while others place the checkpoints so far apart that you can easily lose several minutes of progress if you die.

The presentation is the best thing I can say about Super Comboman. The whole game looks like an animated comic book, and it usually looks great in motion outside of the occasional bit of jaggy edges. The music and sound effects are all pretty solid as well, if a bit repetitive at times. Sadly, the options menu is another place where the game falls flat. There are no resolution or sound options to speak of. The sound and music options are literally just “on” or “off,” and there is no way to turn the announcer or enemy chatter off if you find yourself getting annoyed with their tiny pool of repetitive phrases.

Super Comboman game still 1

Super Comboman is full of missed potential. Sometimes, you can squeeze some fun out of it when you manage to get a big combo going or the smash attack works as intended and sends a helpless mook flying across the screen to crash into a stack of crates or several of his buddies. There is a fun game buried in here somewhere, but those little moments of brilliance are just not worth slogging through its long list of faults. The 2D brawler puzzle-platformer genre isn’t really lacking titles at the moment, and it is just impossible to recommend Super Comboman when games like Guacamelee!, Double Dragon: Neon, Foul Play, and Aces Wild: Manic Brawling Action! exist.

 Frank Streva  is an aspiring game designer that currently just rambles about indie games.